Retailers Dilemma: To grow rapidly or to grow cautiously?

News Release

The Economic Times | Jan 03, 2014

Retailers Dilemma:
To grow rapidly or to grow cautiously?

It is not uncommon for a manufacturing company to enjoy a profitability of around eight percent when the gross contribution is about thirty percent. However, it is rare for a retail chain enjoying a gross contribution of forty percent to have a consistent profitability of three percent (if they manage to make a profit at all).

It is relatively easier for retail chains to show rapid sales growth by opening new stores, however if there is no profit then continuing on this path of growth jeopardizes the very existence of the company.

Retailers Dilemma

Planned Gross Contributions, before Discounting

Source: Vector Research Cell

Planned Gross Contributions, before Discounting

As per a study by Harvard University professors, retailers with consistent high inventory turns have high profitability, resulting in higher share prices and vice versa.

Deciphering the Correlation
Factors that affect inventory turns negatively are surplus and shortages, a reality for retailers across categories. It is not uncommon for stores to be stocked out of popular items while they hold slow moving stock of other items.

The impact of these factors on profitability is as follows:

Improving Inventory Turns – The Challenge
The real challenge for improving inventory turns for a retail chain, consistently, is managing wide variety of products, and dealing with unpredictable movement of products in their life cycle.

Based on the current performance, products across retail categories can be classified as:

Profitability of Modern Retail Chains in 2011

Source: CMIE Data Base.

Profitability of Modern Retail Chains in 2011

This classification means nothing to the end customer. But the understanding is critical for controlling sourcing and making store distribution decisions for improving inventory turns without jeopardising availability. The decisions become more complex when products move across classifications in a time much shorter than the supply chain lead-time. (For example, a garment style may become a ‘hit’ within three weeks of launch while the lead time to source it could be six months).

This environment forces buyers to forecast for a longer horizon resulting in surplus and stockouts. The inventory turns of such retail chains often go haywire, and are only brought under temporary control by discounted sales.

The mistake most retail chains are making is trying to manage the environment by improving forecast accuracy. A flop or hit looks obvious in hindsight; one assumes that with more information, knowledge or experience, one can predict this in future. However, the environment remains unpredictable while discounted sales promotions stay a regular affair

The only way for retailers to achieve higher inventory turns without jeopardizing sales is to move away from forecasting to processes and systems for ‘fast reaction’ to changing trends.

Fast reaction ability is required in the following areas:

  1. Supply Chain
  2. Decisions to Change Stock Levels
  3. Managing New Introductions
  4. "Killing" of Products

1. Supply Chain
The speed of supply chain is determined by the speed at which supplies are made to stores i.e., the speed at which the correct item in the correct quantity is made available. This speed varies based on each vendor’s supply lead time to the stores. Improving all vendors’ lead time is a herculean task. Typically, retailers protect sales by ensuring that inventory is sufficient to meet forecasted sales during the long lead time of vendors. In addition, the vendors’ minimum order restrictions force stores to buy excess quantities. These rules reduce the ability to react quickly to changing demand.

Lead time to stores can be reduced if a retailer sets up a central warehouse to hold inventory, and then supplies the stores an assortment of SKUs (sourced from different vendors), based on daily consumption. This eliminates the need for minimum order on vendors for each store. With a central warehouse, the forecasting of product quantities would be at an aggregated location which can then absorb the variations in sales across stores, thus reducing the total inventory required in the chain. Higher the variability in demand and higher the number of stores to be supplied to, lower is the central warehouse inventory. Inventories at stores will come down due to reduced lead time, which is now the delivery time from the central warehouse. The supply of inventory based on consumption based pull replenishment will ensure that the store’s inventory stays low. The consumption based pull system, as opposed to a reorder point system, also ensures lower slow-moving inventory in stores as supplies are made as per sales rate, not minimum order quantities. Resultant impact is improved availability of items, and reduced stock outs.

Product Life Cycle of various SKUs

It is difficult to predict how and when the classification will change in future.

Product Life Cycle of various SKUs

2. Changing Stock Norms
A system that analyses sale rate daily, helps pick up trends. When supply chain lead time is reduced, and there is a daily check on sales trend, a retail chain has the ability to change inventory norms and correct its buying decisions as soon as the trend is recognized.

3. Managing uncertainty of new product introductions
The current paradigm of buying relies on the judgment of buyers on potential hits or flops. Inventory of new products is placed at stores with the same assumptions and accepting reality when the performance is different from the initial judgment. A better way of managing new products is to accept the inherent uncertainty of the sales of their products. The central warehouse provides a capability to react immediately to sales in stores. When all quantities of new products are placed at the stores, the capability to react is lost. The way out is to place minimum quantity at stores, and have more in the central warehouse.

In some cases, it makes sense to limit introductions in few stores, and observe how they fare. The information can be used to decide on how they will be introduced in other stores and when to make a product continuous replenishment item.

4. "Killing" the SKUs
When new items are continuously introduced, they cannibalise the sales of some existing items in the category. This creates a long tail of SKUs with slow inventory movement. The normal practice is to declare an item dead, when it stops selling. The way to avoid dead inventory is to stop purchasing the SKU while it is still selling.

The company has to define a policy of range limit for each category. Once an item is introduced, another has to be removed from the range. The one which is the new item is substituting or the one with the lowest sale rate. If the discontinued item prevents the new one from being introduced occupying shelf space,(such as furniture) it should be removed within a targeted period with aggressive discounts.

These changes will help a retail chain enjoy consistent high inventory turns without compromising on availability, thus enabling it to exploit sales opportunity in current stores and earn a high return on investment. A high ROI model enables a chain to expand rapidly without facing roadblocks of low profitability and working capital issues.

About Vector Consulting Group

Vector Consulting Group is the leading consulting firm in the space of Theory of Constraints consulting in India, It engages with organizations to help them gain market share by building unique supply chain capabilities that provide a competitive edge in the market. Vector Consulting Group is engaged with India’s most renowned industrial houses such as Tata, Godrej, Bajaj Electricals, Cummins Group, Raymond, and Kirloskar Oil Engines etc.

About AMCF (Association of Management Consulting Firms)

The Association of Management Consulting Firms is the premier international association of firms engaged in the practice of management consulting. Founded in 1929, for 85 years AMCF has been in the forefront of promoting excellence and integrity in the profession.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Other Headlines


Fleetguard Filters, Client of Vector Consulting Group Wins 2016 TOCICO International Achievement Award

Vector Consulting Group, India’s largest management consulting firm in the space of Theory of Constraints, is proud to announce that their client, Fleetguard Filters, is the winner of 2016 TOCICO International Achievement Award, Platinum Level.

read more
The Economic Times

Retailers Dilemma: To grow rapidly or to grow cautiously?

It is relatively easier for retail chains to show rapid sales growth by opening new stores, however if there is no profit then continuing on this path of growth jeopardizes the very existence of the company.

read more
Business Standard

Sourcing Electrical and Lighting: Bajaj is redesigning its distribution supply chain so that channel partners invest less and earn more, faster.

Bajaj Electricals LTD (BEL), the legacy brand in electricals and lighting, has decided to rework its distribution supply chain in order to improve response time, cut costs, and boost profitability.

read more